on the evidence for mushroom intelligence

Shrooms and related goodies
User avatar
ben ttech
MPG Ambassador
Karma Hippie
Karma Hippie
Custom Title: godisnotwhite.com
Has bestowed Karma : 244 times
Received Karma : 151 times
Posts: 7835
Joined: Mon May 25, 2009 2:22 am

on the evidence for mushroom intelligence

Post by ben ttech »

The fungal mind: on the evidence for mushroom intelligence

Mushrooms and other kinds of fungi are often associated with witchcraft and are the subjects of longstanding superstitions. Witches dance inside fairy rings of mushrooms according to German folklore, while a French fable warns that anyone foolish enough to step inside these ‘sorcerer’s rings’ will be cursed by enormous toads with bulging eyes. These impressions come from the poisonous and psychoactive peculiarities of some species, as well as the overnight appearance of toadstool ring-formations.

Given the magical reputation of the fungi, claiming that they might be conscious is dangerous territory for a credentialled scientist. But in recent years, a body of remarkable experiments have shown that fungi operate as individuals, engage in decision-making, are capable of learning, and possess short-term memory. These findings highlight the spectacular sensitivity of such ‘simple’ organisms, and situate the human version of the mind within a spectrum of consciousness that might well span the entire natural world.

Before we explore the evidence for fungal intelligence, we need to consider the slippery vocabulary of cognitive science. Consciousness implies awareness, evidence of which might be expressed in an organism’s responsiveness or sensitivity to its surroundings. There is an implicit hierarchy here, with consciousness present in a smaller subset of species, while sensitivity applies to every living thing. Until recently, most philosophers and scientists awarded consciousness to big-brained animals and excluded other forms of life from this honour. The problem with this favouritism, as the cognitive psychologist Arthur Reber has pointed out, is that it’s impossible to identify a threshold level of awareness or responsiveness that separates conscious animals from the unconscious. We can escape this dilemma, however, once we allow ourselves to identify different versions of consciousness across a continuum of species, from apes to amoebas. That’s not to imply that all organisms possess rich emotional lives and are capable of thinking, although fungi do appear to express the biological rudiments of these faculties.

Just what are mushrooms? It turns out that this question doesn’t have a simple answer. Mushrooms are the reproductive organs produced by fungi that spend most of their lives below ground in the form of microscopic filaments called hyphae. These hyphae, in turn, branch to form colonies called mycelia. Mycelia spread out in three dimensions within soil and leaf litter, absorbing water and feeding on roots, wood, and the bodies of dead insects and other animals. Each of the hyphae in a mycelium is a tube filled with pressurised fluid, and extends at its tip. The materials that power this elongation are conveyed in little packages called vesicles, whose motion is guided along an interior system of rails by proteins that operate as motors. The speed and direction of hyphal extension, as well as the positions of branch formation, are determined by patterns of vesicle delivery. This growth mechanism responds, second by second, to changes in temperature, water availability, and other opportunities and hardships imposed by the surrounding environment.

Each mycelium is like a snowflake, with a shape that arises at one place and time in the Universe
Hyphae can detect ridges on surfaces, grow around obstacles, and deploy a patch-and-repair system if they’re damaged. These actions draw upon an array of protein sensors and signalling pathways that link the external physical or chemical inputs to cellular response. The electrical activity of the cell is also sensitive to changes in the environment. Oscillations in the voltage across the hyphal membrane have been likened to nerve impulses in animals, but their function in fungi is poorly understood. Hyphae react to confinement too, altering their growth rate, becoming narrower and branching less frequently. The fungus adapts to the texture of the soil and the anatomy of plant and animal tissues as it pushes ahead and forages for food. It’s not thinking in the sense that a brained animal thinks – but the fundamental mechanisms that allow a hypha to process information are the same as those at work in our bodies.


We tend to associate consciousness and intelligence with the appearance of wilfulness or intentionality – that is, decision-making that results in a particular behavioural outcome. Whether or not humans have free will, we take actions that seem wilful: she finished her coffee, whereas her friend left her cup half full. Fungi express simpler versions of individualistic behaviour all the time. Patterns of branch formation are a good example of their seemingly idiosyncratic nature. Every young fungal colony assumes a unique shape, because the precise timing and positions of branch emergence from a hypha vary. This variation isn’t due to genetic differences, since identical clones from a single parent fungus still create colonies with unique shapes. Although the overall form is highly predictable, its detailed geometry is usually irreproducible. Each mycelium is like a snowflake, with a shape that arises at one place and time in the Universe.

Fungi also show evidence of learning and memory. Working with fungi isolated from grassland soil, German mycologists measured the effect of temperature changes on the growth of mycelia. When heated up quickly for a few hours, the mycelia stopped growing. When the temperature was reduced again, they bounced back from the episode by forming a series of smaller colonies from different spots across the original mycelium.

Meanwhile, a different set of mycelia were exposed to a mild temperature stress before the application of a more severe temperature shock. Colonies that had been ‘primed’ in this way resumed normal growth very swiftly after the severe stress, and continued their smooth expansion, rather than recovering here and there in the form of smaller colonies. This outcome suggests that they developed some defensive mechanisms that enabled them to brush off the more severe stress. The fungi retained this biochemical memory for up to 24 hours after the mild temperature shock, but forgot soon afterwards, and succumbed to additional heat stress as if they had learned nothing.

The single-celled fungus present as baker’s and brewer’s yeast, Saccharomyces cerevisiae, has also shown the capacity for cellular memory. Yeasts primed by salt exposure become better at responding to other kinds of chemical stress that follow. Memorisation appears to be present in other microorganisms, but filamentous fungi are particularly interesting because mycelia can spread over large areas and transmit information over long distances through their hyphae. That’s very different from learning and memory within populations of dispersed cells. Decomposer fungi that rot wood manifest this information transfer as they fan out beneath the leaf litter, searching for dead and damaged trees, fallen branches and other sources of food. When one part of the mycelium finds some woody debris, nutrients extracted are distributed across the whole colony, which focuses its growth away from barren to fertile locations on the forest floor. The mycelium is operating as more than a simple sum of its individual hyphae; it’s like an integrated multicellular organism.

By responding to the need to create the shortest connections between its food stations, the slime mould achieved the same economies as human architects

When researchers followed the transfer of nutrients in the lab, further remarkable discoveries were in store. In a tray of soil, hyphae were observed to make contact with a block of beechwood. They grew over its surface and penetrated the solid structure, secreting enzymes that broke down the polymers in the wood and released sugars that fuelled their metabolism. Once the fungus exhausted the energy in the woodblock, it grew out in all directions, foraging once again. Here is where the mindfulness of the fungus becomes clear. When a mycelium located a second block of beechwood and was then placed in a fresh tray, it would emerge from the same side of the block that had allowed it to hit pay-dirt the first time. It remembered that growing from a particular face of the woodblock had resulted in a food reward before, and so sought to repeat its prior success. The fungus in these experiments showed spatial recognition, memory and intelligence. It’s a conscious organism.

Simple forms of learning and memory have been studied in slime moulds for many years. Slime moulds are not fungi, but relatives of that microscopic celebrity of the biology classroom, the amoeba. They form glistening yellow colonies called plasmodia that ooze over rotting wood and eat bacteria. These gooey monsters can cover the entire stump of a tree when there’s enough moisture. Smaller versions can be nurtured with oat flakes in the lab, where the flattened plasmodia move from flake to flake, keeping the whole organism alive with a network of veins that pulse with fluid. In a 2010 experiment, when its plasmodium was surrounded by oat flakes arranged in the same pattern as the cities circling the Japanese capital, it created a pattern that was strikingly similar to the layout of the railway system around Tokyo. By responding to the need to create the shortest connections between its food stations, the slime mould achieved the same economies as human architects.

The behavioural complexity of fungi increases when they interact with living trees and shrubs rather than dead wood. Some of these relationships are destructive while others are mutually supportive. Pathogenic fungi can be very cunning in how they feed on plants and evade their defences. Mycorrhizal fungi are more cooperative, penetrating tree roots and establishing tight physical connections through which they pass water and dissolved minerals to the trees, in return for food produced by photosynthesis. The mycelium of the mycorrhizal fungus operates as an accessory root system for the tree, spreading over a larger territory with its filamentous hyphae than the plant can cover with its own rootlets.

This complex symbiosis relies on continuous chemical communication between the fungus and the plant that affects the development of both partners. Mycorrhizas support the productivity of the entire ecosystem, spurring some fungal enthusiasts to reimagine forests as superorganisms connected through a ‘wood-wide web’ of fungi. This is an intriguing idea, but allusions to the internet create problems. For starters, it does a disservice to the fungi: unlike the internet, fungi generate their own information through active interactions with their vegetal partners. Secondly, the computer metaphor has been adopted by those who attribute supernatural properties to the fungi, which is one of the reasons why fungal behaviour has often been (wrongly) relegated to the fringes of ‘real’ science. While an expert on fruit flies can tell a fellow biologist that they study insect behaviour without provoking mirth, any mention of studying mushroom cognition is almost certain to raise eyebrows.

Fungal expressions of consciousness are certainly very simple. But they do align with an emerging consensus that, while the human mind might be particular in its refinements, it’s typical in its cellular mechanisms. Experiments on fungal consciousness are exciting for mycologists because they’ve made space for the study of behaviour within the broader field of research on the biology of fungi. Those who study animal behaviour do so without reference to the molecular interactions of their muscles; likewise, mycologists can learn a great deal about fungi simply by paying closer attention to what they do. As crucial players in the ecology of the planet, these fascinating organisms deserve our full attention as genuine partners in sustaining a functional biosphere.
"disaster is the mother of necessity" rSin

User avatar
Intrinsic
Advanced Grower
Karma Hippie
Karma Hippie
Has bestowed Karma : 828 times
Received Karma : 844 times
Posts: 6388
Joined: Thu May 21, 2009 10:51 am

on the evidence for mushroom intelligence

Post by Intrinsic »

Did you know that with some trees, information is spread through connecting mycelium. An individual tree can be affected by external environment yet surrounding trees will respond additionally.

User avatar
rSin
Karma Hippie
Karma Hippie
Custom Title: world where everone gets
Location: neck deep
Has bestowed Karma : 953 times
Received Karma : 651 times
Posts: 6229
Joined: Fri Mar 26, 2010 8:12 pm

on the evidence for mushroom intelligence

Post by rSin »

makes me think of all those amazon prime trucks out driving...


yes, they are often symbiote
nutrients from far further away than their roots stretch

how deep can their networks spread?
the intolerance of the old order is emerging from the rosy mist in which it has hitherto been obscured.

User avatar
Intrinsic
Advanced Grower
Karma Hippie
Karma Hippie
Has bestowed Karma : 828 times
Received Karma : 844 times
Posts: 6388
Joined: Thu May 21, 2009 10:51 am

on the evidence for mushroom intelligence

Post by Intrinsic »

Big, largest single organism on the planet. Maybe Ever..

but for sheer number of individuals on the planet it's
The Bacteriophage.



I wonder if mycelium and bacteriophage sharing physical information. How the Mycelium links to the plant kingdom network that it isn't already connected to it. Jes trippy ecology speculation.
viruses;; am I right?

Online
User avatar
dill786
Karma Jackpot
Karma Jackpot
Custom Title: kuchisabishii
Has bestowed Karma : 448 times
Received Karma : 319 times
Posts: 830
Joined: Sat Oct 14, 2017 1:45 am

on the evidence for mushroom intelligence

Post by dill786 »

mushroom slime mold help design the tokyo underground rail system.

look it up !!

User avatar
ripper5
Karma Shaman
Karma Shaman
Has bestowed Karma : 1228 times
Received Karma : 794 times
Posts: 1534
Joined: Sun Feb 21, 2010 1:39 am

on the evidence for mushroom intelligence

Post by ripper5 »

Shrooms jam out! Wired for sound! :emp:

User avatar
rSin
Karma Hippie
Karma Hippie
Custom Title: world where everone gets
Location: neck deep
Has bestowed Karma : 953 times
Received Karma : 651 times
Posts: 6229
Joined: Fri Mar 26, 2010 8:12 pm

on the evidence for mushroom intelligence

Post by rSin »

the project first started sprouting in Peru in 2019. There, Yvonne and Josh met a friend who had a MIDI biodata sonification device, which measures electrical fluctuations through sensors attached directly to any living thing—plant, fungus, or otherwise. That data is then translated into MIDI notes, which can be played by a synthesizer or computer software. They drove around the Sacred Valley, home to Machu Picchu, and started testing the device on various plants, amazed at the possibilities opening before their ears. Yvonne and Josh quickly bought a sonification device as soon as they got back to Austin, and the process of playing music with mushrooms has been inspiring

https://kutx.org/features/the-secret-so ... mushrooms/
the intolerance of the old order is emerging from the rosy mist in which it has hitherto been obscured.

User avatar
ripper5
Karma Shaman
Karma Shaman
Has bestowed Karma : 1228 times
Received Karma : 794 times
Posts: 1534
Joined: Sun Feb 21, 2010 1:39 am

on the evidence for mushroom intelligence

Post by ripper5 »

Makes sense. Mother Nature is large & in charge!

User avatar
ripper5
Karma Shaman
Karma Shaman
Has bestowed Karma : 1228 times
Received Karma : 794 times
Posts: 1534
Joined: Sun Feb 21, 2010 1:39 am

on the evidence for mushroom intelligence

Post by ripper5 »

Going to have to give this a listen next time I consume them. :tonka:

User avatar
ben ttech
MPG Ambassador
Karma Hippie
Karma Hippie
Custom Title: godisnotwhite.com
Has bestowed Karma : 244 times
Received Karma : 151 times
Posts: 7835
Joined: Mon May 25, 2009 2:22 am

on the evidence for mushroom intelligence

Post by ben ttech »

my first mushroom experience was 14grams

seemed id accessed channels that allowed discerning conversations by other inteligences
a gallerys view on other more serious conversations than id ever suspected

months later
the next two were 7grams
and in them

these others would stop and offer the comment

'you again....'
and then returning to their pursuits


this thread original article shows how experimentive science has shows fungi possess minor building blocks which consciousness would have to have

were so poor at quantifying consciousness in humans

no wonder we cant see it elsewhere...
"disaster is the mother of necessity" rSin

Post Reply