US WA: FELONIES DISMISSED AS COURT RULING TRICKLES DOWN

Know of anything interesting to share with your fellow cannabis crusaders?
User avatar
WhiteHotAfterburner
Advanced Grower
Karma Hippie
Karma Hippie
Custom Title: Turbine Powered Toker
Location: In an F35...above you..jus sayin.
Has bestowed Karma : 521 times
Received Karma : 217 times
Posts: 6770
Joined: Thu May 21, 2009 12:02 am

US WA: FELONIES DISMISSED AS COURT RULING TRICKLES DOWN

Post by WhiteHotAfterburner »

Felonies dismissed as court ruling trickles down
By JESSIE STENSLAND
Whidbey News Times Assistant editor
May 08 2009

The Island County prosecutor was forced to dismiss felony charges against four people because of a recent U.S. Supreme Court decision.

The ruling will likely affect many misdemeanor cases, as well as the caseloads for police and prosecutors in the future.

“The reality is that a lot of guns and drugs won’t be found,” Prosecutor Greg Banks said.

Banks said Arizona v. Gant was a landmark case because it changes a long-standing practice for police in searching cars after an occupant is arrested.

In compliance with a 1981 Supreme Court case, police used to routinely search the compartment of a car after arresting an occupant. The reasoning for the search, as laid out by the high court, was to remove any weapons that the arrested person may brandish against the officer or to prevent the suspect from destroying evidence.

But in the recent case, the justices ruled 9-0 that this reasoning was faulty if the person being arrested was handcuffed or secured in a police car.

In other words, Banks said, the police normally can’t perform a warrantless car search “incident to arrest” unless the officer has a reason to believe that evidence related to the offense of arrest is in the car or if the suspect can reach into the car.

Of course, the officers can still apply for a search warrant whenever they feel it’s necessary to search a vehicle. Or they can ask permission to search the car.

Defense attorneys are pleased with the ruling.

“There’s no question it’s a landmark decision for defense, but the reality is that it’s a practical one as well,” said Coupeville attorney Darrin Hall, pointing out that the original reasoning for the warrantless searches simply didn’t make sense.

Island County Sheriff Mark Brown, who was a state trooper for 26 years, said he’s made many dozens of felony arrests over the years based on searches incident to arrest. Many of those times, he arrested a driver for driving without a license and ended up finding illegal guns or drugs in the car.

Undersheriff Kelly Mauck predicts that the ruling won’t diminish the workload for officers because they’ll probably apply for more warrants in the future.

Oak Harbor Police Chief Rick Wallace said the decision likely will result in fewer arrests in the future, but he doesn’t think the change will be great.

“It’s one less tool the officers have in their toolbox,” he said, “but I don’t see it completely hamstringing us.”


http://www.pnwlocalnews.com/whidbey/wnt ... 09407.html

Once less arrest or charge (or reduction of charges) is a great step in the right direction!


Take care all,
WHAB

User avatar
ben ttech
MPG Ambassador
Karma Hippie
Karma Hippie
Custom Title: godisnotwhite.com
Has bestowed Karma : 389 times
Received Karma : 240 times
Posts: 8234
Joined: Mon May 25, 2009 2:22 am

US WA: FELONIES DISMISSED AS COURT RULING TRICKLES DOWN

Post by ben ttech »

thanks for being soft on crime whab....
"disaster is the mother of necessity" rSin

User avatar
Jolly Roger
good karma
good karma
Posts: 179
Joined: Wed May 20, 2009 10:53 pm

US WA: FELONIES DISMISSED AS COURT RULING TRICKLES DOWN

Post by Jolly Roger »

As Nelson of the Simpsons sez--

HA! HA!
Thank God for Beer, Football, and Women :pirate:

Post Reply